The Paradox of Goodwill: Why Self-interest May Not Be a Bad Thing

Benjamin Bonetti Therapy Online Coaching

I am frequently confronted with questions about the motives that underpin human actions. The question of whether our acts of goodwill are genuinely altruistic or subtly self-serving is particularly intriguing.

This question not only challenges our understanding of human nature but also has profound implications for our mental health. 

Goodwill — the intention to do good to others out of kindness — is often hailed as a hallmark of morality. However, when we delve deeper into the complexity of human behaviour, it becomes apparent that our motives are not always purely altruistic. Beneath the surface, could there be a self-serving agenda at play? 

Research in the field of evolutionary psychology offers a valuable perspective on this issue.

It suggests that altruism, including goodwill, may have evolved as a survival strategy. By helping others, early humans could have increased their social standing, gained allies, and improved their chances of survival and reproduction. This concept, known as 'reciprocal altruism', suggests that our acts of goodwill may be subtly driven by self-interest.

Moreover, research in neuroscience has found that performing acts of goodwill activates the brain's reward system, releasing 'feel-good' hormones such as dopamine and oxytocin. This suggests that we might perform acts of goodwill because they make us feel good, adding another layer of self-interest to our altruistic actions.

However, acknowledging these self-serving motives does not diminish the value of goodwill. Instead, it can foster greater self-awareness, authenticity, and resilience, thereby contributing to our mental health. Recognising that it's okay to benefit from acts of goodwill can free us from the pressure to be selflessly altruistic, a standard that can be mentally exhausting to uphold.

Yet, there's another piece of the puzzle that we need to consider: cognitive biases. These are systematic errors in our thinking that can skew our perception and interpretation of events. For instance, the 'self-serving bias' might lead us to view our own acts of goodwill as purely altruistic while interpreting others' acts of goodwill as self-serving. This bias can distort our understanding of goodwill and fuel conflict and misunderstanding. 

Another relevant cognitive bias is the 'halo effect', where our perception of a person's goodwill can spill over to influence our judgement of their other traits. This bias can create unrealistic expectations and disappointment, leading to mental distress. 

So, how can we navigate these complexities? As a counsellor, I recommend the practice of mindfulness. By cultivating a non-judgmental awareness of our thoughts and feelings, we can recognise our self-serving motives and cognitive biases more clearly. This increased self-awareness can help us to practice goodwill in a more authentic and balanced way, contributing to our mental health. 

In conclusion, the question of whether our acts of goodwill are genuinely altruistic or subtly self-serving is not a binary one. It's not a matter of either/or but rather both/and. By recognising and embracing the paradox of goodwill, we can foster greater self-awareness, authenticity, and resilience, thereby promoting better mental health. Remember, it's okay to benefit from acts of goodwill. After all, goodwill that fosters well-being, both for others and ourselves, is truly something to celebrate. 

Are you feeling overwhelmed, stressed, or simply wish to gain a better understanding of yourself? We understand that life can sometimes become challenging, and it's essential to have a supportive hand to guide you through those times. 

We are able to provide you with professional, compassionate, and confidential support right in the comfort of your own home. No more commute, no more waiting rooms, no more adjusting your schedule to fit in appointments.

We cater to a broad range of mental health concerns – from anxiety, depression, stress management, to more complex issues. We utilise various therapeutic approaches to provide personalised treatment that resonates with your unique experiences and goals.

Taking the first step towards therapy can be daunting, but remember, every journey begins with a single step. So, why not take that step today towards a healthier, happier you?